supercell feat. Miku Hatsune World is Mine 1/8 (Good Smile) review

By James. Filed in Figures Pics, Figures Reviews  |  
Tags:
TOP del.icio.us digg

World is Mine Christmas version

More under the cut

I believe i’ll be the only one giving a bad review to this one, please read my conclusion at the end of the post before insulting/throwing rocks at me ^^

World Is Mine is only getting three Exelica out of five.

Good: Framed base is awesome, looks great on a wall

Bad: Sculpt not so awesome (it’s ok but not really detailled), paint job is not precise at all (dots, sloppy painting and difference of colors between the samples), and the quality check is awful, you have little chance to get a flawless WIM (from what i’ve seen)

0008

0009

0007

00010

0006

0004

0003

00013

00012

0002

0001

00014

00019

00020

00022

00023

00024

00025

00026

00027

00016

00015

00017

00019

World is Mine 1/8 (Good Smile)

World Is Mine (Jintoo)

Wow great quality control, no writing at all on the base, if you think i was harsh with this review, this picture says it all … My friend got this WIM, his version got an ok paint work but no World is Mine inscription … (edit : now another friend told me the hair on his WIM is ending semi translucid … and his base is poorly painted too …)

So in total with the seven WIM i’ve seen/had in hands, only three got correct painting and one doesn’t have the WIM text. I’m sorry but i think it’s the worst control quality check i’ve ever seen, Good Smile did report the figure, but seeing the results, i don’t know why they did … But at least they’re making their nendos right, so it’s fine, no ? …

I’m pretty mad at Good Smile right now, so i hope Black Rock Shooter is really going to be awesome …

Now for World Is Mine, it’s still a good figure if you plan to put it as a frame on the wall, it will look great and it’s very original. And at least on the wall, you won’t see the paint problems or the missing text ;)

I’m sorry i’m very mean with this figure, i do love my World Is Mine a lot, but it’s really sad to see this much problems on a figure pushed back for a reason we don’t even know.

Hope you all got a version without flaw ! (meronpan got a kinda correct version, check his review for macro pics here)

The review is up at Shadonia and Kodomut

Others reviews here and here

And Happy New Year to you all !

World is Mine Christmas version

Popularity: 97% [?]

  • Share/Bookmark

48 Comments

  1. Comment by Smithy:

    She does look terrific overall but it’s sad to hear so many have quality issues, getting a flawed figure can really ruin the entire experience…
    Smithy´s last blog ..Azusa Nakano nendoroid My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    yeah , it’s too sad to see so many problems with her …

    [Reply]

  2. Comment by Leonia:

    Elle est belle tout de même. C’est vrai que la sculpture n’est pas aussi impressionnante que d’autres, mais bon, l’ensemble demeure agréable. J’aime beaucoup le style et la base. Tes photos sont jolies, même si tu as dis que tu avais galéré. Félicitation chou !
    Leonia´s last blog ..Happy New Year 2010 My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Mais oui qu’elle est belle, mais les differences entre les figs sont intolérables … Celle de Jinto n’a meme pas d’inscription, on paye quand meme dans les 100 euros pour avoir une fig PVC, alors si elle est pas complete ou avec des tachez de peinture …

    [Reply]

    Leonia Reply:

    Oui, il m’en avait parlé. Ca me rappelle beaucoup la Alice de AxO, qui avait des soucis d’une à l’autre (avec les accessoires, sans la queue et cie). Avec la promo qu’ils ont fait, et le retard de deux-trois mois, elle aurait du être parfaite.
    Leonia´s last blog ..First Year ! My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Lol oui la Alice sans queue …

  3. Comment by Katsura-chan:

    I don’t get hooked up by this one … don’t know why but whatever i like it or not, it’s very sad to have such hazardous result on different copies.
    Slapdash work shouldn’t be distributed at all …
    You did manage to do nice photos anyhow :)
    Katsura-chan´s last blog ..Happy New Year My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Yeah well this one is really made to be put on a wall and it looks great that way ^^

    I agree that it shouldn’t be put for sale if they’re not sure to do a good paint job :/

    And thanks :)

    [Reply]

  4. Comment by Aka:

    Nice shots with the Christmas lighting in the background! I really like the mood it creates.

    It’s too bad that the QC doesn’t seem good, though I have no noticed any issues in the pictures I’ve seen. However in person it’s an entirely different matter. I hope I’m not disappointed when mine arrives, I don’t think I should be, she still looks great I think.

    I find it odd that there’d be missing text, thta seems to say ‘bootleg’ to me more than a QC issue. But then, bootlegs are usually pretty terrible quality, and if the rest of the figure was fine it would be hard to believe it were a bootleg. That’s really strange, I really like GSC but they seem to be lacking as of recent. Tons of delays and then seemingly nothing to show for the delay. It makes me a little nervous about all the upcoming figures I have pre-ordered from GSC. I’m not going to cancel them of course, but I do feel somewhat uneasy.

    -Aka

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Hi :)

    Thanks , yeah i loved taking the pics in front of the christmas tree for my 3 last reviews ^^

    To see some paint dots and bad finish , you can check the pic on white background , you should see them :)

    It’s for these moment that i should have a macro lens but i don’t :(

    The missing text one is not a bootleg, as it’s from Ami Ami. So it’s really another mistake from GSC … I was clearly disapointed by GSC this year (Hiyori Pixy) and now with this one … They should stop their nendoroids spam and makes great figures again … (and yes i do hate nendos and figmas :( )

    At least Alter never disapoints (and Max Factory too)

    I hope Black Rock Shooter is going to be awesome …

    [Reply]

    Aka Reply:

    I’m not a fan of the Nendoroids either, though figmas have grown on me. Drossel and Kagamiku helped out in that respect.

    Do you mean the paint dots on the base? That is rather strange. That seems like something that would have been easily fixable as well.

    Alter and Max Factory disappoint if you buy older figures by them, I have a few that aren’t super great. Colours are off, sculpting is very simplistic, or pieces of them seem to be entirely different colours than the rest. But their current line ups always seem quite good.

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Paints dots on the base and the petals awfully painted (some are like doubled :D )

    Glad someone shares my not love for Nendoroids :o . I mean i have some and it was good at first but now for one scale figure annonced, there is like 10 nendoroids …

    I have lots of Max Factory and Alter old figures , no probleme with them, and it’s surely not 1 or 2 good figures out of 7 ^^

    Aka Reply:

    My example for Alter would be their Eri Sawachika, her skin colour is quite terrible. And an example for Max Factory would be their Mao figure which also has off colour skin. Additionally I find that Max Factory figure to have a rather simplistic sculpt, though admittedly a very simplistic figure in the first place.

    I totally do not understand why they release so many Nendoroids other than they seem to be enormously popular, which is something I also can’t seem to comprehend. They aren’t cute… Though I admit Kodomut uses them to produce some fun posts.

    James Reply:

    Yeah i saw your Eri review and Mao too ^^

    As for Max Factory, for me, they’re the best paint wise, i love the color they use and the paint job is always of high quality. And i have all the Shinning swimsuit figures minus Mao ^^

    And Kodomut does indeed do fun posts with his nendos, but i see nendos on every blog and that bores me now :( . I began to hate them after seeing all the releases and preorders for them … Way too much exposition for them …

  5. Comment by Blowfish:

    Whilr I wouldnt buy her I love that look on her face as if shed start humping the viewer any minute.The bad quality control is a real bummer though.I cant understand how this got through QC.On another hand I cant say how awesome your pictures are.Your christmas tree makes such an awesome background.Its like everywheres something going on.
    This makes me wanna have a DSLR so oooo bad oh and I wish you a happy new year mate ^^
    Blowfish´s last blog ..Masters of Queens Blade Excellent!! Official Figure & Visual Book My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    I don’t like these pics at all ^^ and LOL about your comment on the face :D

    Happy New Year to you too !

    [Reply]

    Blowfish Reply:

    Well those pictures arent really useable to spot and judge a figure due to the background but I like them anyway.
    And well Im serious about that face XD
    Thats the way I like the girls ^^
    Blowfish´s last blog ..Masters of Queens Blade Excellent!! Official Figure & Visual Book My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    :D

    Smithy Reply:

    “As if shed start humping the viewer any minute.”

    And that’s bad how? <__>
    Smithy´s last blog ..Happy New Year! My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

  6. Comment by meronpan:

    hmmm really weird about the base completely missing the inscription -_- usually that screams bootleg, but you say it’s from amiami? very strange/disappointing that such a glaring fault made it through ;_;

    i’m usually less critical, but we’ll see how my macro lens treats her :P
    meronpan´s last blog ..BLACK★ROCK SHOOTER My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Yep it’s from AmiAmi , can’t wait to see your pics , but maybe you’re gonna get a good copy. But still i’ve seen 6 copies , only two “perfect” so yeah …

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    After looking at my friend’s WIM , maybe it’s indeed a bootleg , is it me or the armbands on her left hand are different ? :/

    [Reply]

  7. Comment by Chappy:

    She looks good if you look from far, but lke you said poor QC so bad if looking near. >.<
    Anyway, I don't think your friend got a bootleg. I visit China forum often, but there is no news of WIM bootleg. O.O
    Chappy´s last blog ..Chappy’s 2009 My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Yes, it’s not a boot, just awful quality control …

    Happy New year Chappy ^^

    [Reply]

  8. Comment by Jyuichi:

    Well my WIM is looks pretty nice, I had no idea I got so llucky. That missing text is absolutely unacceptable, just rediculous. :(

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Hello :)

    Yeah maybe you can consider yourself lucky ^^

    And yes the missing text is not good but my friend doesn’t want to send her back because it’ll be too long :(

    [Reply]

  9. Comment by FaS:

    WOW, THIS IS AMAZING. The only cell I have is a lasercell from that Resident Evil 5 premium edition lol. But this….wow, omfg. I seriously need to get my figure game up….
    FaS´s last blog ..Winter 2010 V2 New Shows/Subbed Trailers My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Hello :)

    I didn’t get the Resident Evil 5 collector’s :( but i didn’t like the game anyway , big disapointement :(

    And yes you should buy some figures and give them love !

    [Reply]

  10. Comment by super rats:

    Interesting. I know that there is a bit of variance from figure to figure, but it’s kind of odd to have the text totally missing from one of them. Maybe with the delays maybe there’s different runs of the figure accounting for difference, not that it makes it good, just guessing.
    super rats´s last blog ..Black Rock Shooter My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Hey :)

    Yeah, a little variance is fine, but not that much and the missing text and the paint finish on the base are unacceptable :(

    [Reply]

  11. Comment by Persocom:

    nice pictures, hopefully when we eventually get ours it has the writing and ends up being one of the better made ones. that’s odd how the quality differs so much between each one. that’s strange how they could manage to release ones without the text

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    I really hope yours is going to be good ! Don’t forget to post here again to tell me, and maybe give me one pic so i can add yours to the count :)

    [Reply]

  12. Comment by softz:

    Oh no, this doesn’t sound nice to me. I just ordered mine last month. I hope I don’t get too disappointed with mine. Probably, I’ll just apply you idea and hang it on the wall if it turns out bad for me. And your photos, they are great!
    softz´s last blog ..OO Gundam Model Kit Assembled! My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Hi :)

    You should put her on the wall anyway, i mean it was the way she was designed for :)

    And i sounds really harsh on my review, but my two WIM are on my desk besides me and i’m happy with them :) . And thankk you :)

    [Reply]

  13. Comment by Yuina:

    Tiens, alors je suis pas la seule à avoir une WIM dont le bout des couettes est translucide ? je me demandais justement si c’était normal…
    Humpf, à quoi bon en avoir acheté deux alors que tu m’avais dit qu’elle ne te bottait pas tant que ça ? ^^;

    M’enfin, je fais pas trop trop attention aux défauts de WIM puisque je suis en adoration devant ma BRS mouahahahahahahaha ;P
    Yuina´s last blog ..Velvet – Odin Sphere [E2046 gathering] My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Comme elle se la joue la chinoise avec sa BRS !

    Moi j’en aurais deux , na ! (vive les précos faites sans noter …)

    [Reply]

  14. Comment by enrius:

    Sad to hear that she faced several QC problems. Before that I already read the outrage from a Taiwan figure forum about how bad was the QC of WIM done. But I didn’t expect to turn out this bad. On the other hand, from I have seen, BRS was delivered nicely. Perhaps GSC put more effort on BRS?

    With that being said, you still managed to take great photos of WIM. ^^

    Oh, and a belated happy new year!

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Thanks , happy new year to you too !

    Glad to know i’m not the only one having problems with this WIM :D

    [Reply]

  15. Comment by phossil:

    I dont entirely like this figure mainly because its on a frame and I dont like my figures to be on that way.
    Anyway i like your review and pictures.
    phossil´s last blog ..New Year Resolutions My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Well it does looks great on wall :)

    I believe it’s the only way to correctly display this one :)

    [Reply]

  16. Comment by Chrono-Kun:

    Je n’ai jamais beaucoup accroché à ce “dérivé” de Miku Hatsune. Je préfère largement BRS. :P
    En tout cas, même s’il est évident qu’elle possède quelques défauts, elle reste pas moins un fantastique objet de déco pour son intérieur. :)
    Au faite, si ça continue, tu vas toutes les acheter en double tes figs …. j’ai cru comprendre que tu allais recevoir deux BRS. :D
    Chanceux ou tête en l’air … ^^
    Chrono-Kun´s last blog ..BeFA 2010 – Best Figures Awards – 3rd Edition My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    C’est tellement la classe de recevoir les figs en double et de galerer pour pouvoir les payer … que du bonheur !

    Bref tête en l’air ne suffit pas pour me definir, ca serait plutot gros boulet :D

    [Reply]

  17. Comment by Q:

    It is a bit surprising to see a number of quality problems on the figure. No text, one leg lacks the shiny surface etc. It sure sounds like poor quality control to me. It’s even more shocking to hear from you that out of 7 that you have seen personally only 3 got done properly, and I didn’t hear much of this problem over in ToysDaily forum last month. This sure baffles me a bit.

    I guess you can’t return it back to the online store for a new one in this case? One way or the other it’s still kinda disappointing to know. I hope the BRS you receive will be in good quality.
    Q´s last blog ..Asia Game Show 2009 My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Only two nearly perfect out of 10 now ^^

    Seen others with big flaws …

    Won’t sent any back, because they’re nearly all with problems, it’s really a production thing :(

    BRS doesn’t seems to have any QC problem so it’ll probably be fine :)

    [Reply]

  18. Comment by kyn:

    une très jolie pièce tout de même …. et vraiment dommage pour les différence surtout quand on voit le prix O_o
    très jolies photos que tu nous offre ;)

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Merci, oui vraiment dommage …

    [Reply]

  19. Comment by Dorothée:

    Félicitations pour faire parti des 50 gagnants du concours photo du WHL4U !
    Tes photos sont vraiment magnifiques.
    Je fais de la photo depuis un certain nombre d’années, mais j’ai énormément de mal avec les photos de figurines…
    Moi, j’ai perdu, mais le plus important c’est de participer !

    Sinon pour cette figurine, j’avais hésité à la prendre à l’époque, parce que pour moi, ce sont les Nendoroid en premier, et le reste si je peux… et à l’époque je ne pouvais pas !
    J’aime bien le principe de mettre la figurine sur le mur… par contre ça doit être une belle galère pour la poussière !
    Dorothée´s last blog ..News Nendoroid : Nendoroid : Nakano Azusa My ComLuv Profile

    [Reply]

    James Reply:

    Awww je te remercies d’etre passée me prévenir pour le concours, sinon je n’aurais jamais su ^^

    Je ne me souvenais meme plus avoir envoyé une photo lol, il m’a fallu 10 minutes pour comprendre de quel concours tu parlais (et puis je venais de me reveiller, ca n’aide pas :D )

    Bref je n’aime pas du tout ma série de photos de WIM, mais content si tu apprécie :)

    Oui je sais que toi c’est surtout nendos, les nendos c’est tres chouettes en grand nombre, ca fait vraiment classe dans une collection. Mais je n’accroche pas, de part la petite taille et toujours la meme pose et type de visage. Je trouve ca ennuyeux, mais ca n’est que mon avis ^^

    Bref merci ;)

    [Reply]

Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. Hatsune Miku ~ World is Mine ~ 初音ミク ワールドイズマイン « WAWAWA 忘れ物
  2. Reviews | World is Mine – Good Smile Company | Shadonia

Leave a Reply